Author date | Quality | Study design | Covariates included D=demo graphic; W=work place; O=other | Tenure measurement | Newest worker group | Injury label | Newest workers sign. Elevated risk? | Evidence synthesis (support/no support) |
Chau et al 20103 | High | Cohort | W | Time at firm | <1 year | Fall, same level | No | Support* |
Fall, lower level | Yes | |||||||
Handling material | Yes | |||||||
Handling during assembly | No | |||||||
Lifting equipment | No | |||||||
Operating machines | No | |||||||
Collision with object | No | |||||||
Collision with vehicle | No | |||||||
Hand tools | No | |||||||
Other | No | |||||||
Chau 2014 | High | Cohort | D, W | Time at firm | <1 year | Women, all acute injuries | No | No support |
Men, all acute injuries | Yes | |||||||
Kubo 2013 | Medium | Longitudinal | D, W | Time at particular job | 0–12 months | All acute injuries | Yes | Support |
Sahl 1997a | High | Cohort | D | Time in a particular job | <1 year | Dog attacks | Yes | No support |
Fall, same level | Yes | |||||||
Walking | No | |||||||
Step on Sharp object | Yes | |||||||
Strike on gate | No | |||||||
Lift object | No | |||||||
Sahl 1997b | Medium | Cohort | D | Time at firm | 0–6 months | All acute injuries | Yes | Support |
Breslin and Smith4 | High | Cohort | D, W | Time at firm | <1 month | Contact with objects | Yes | Support |
Falls | Yes | |||||||
Bodily reaction or exertion | Yes |
Please refer online supplementary appendix file for full reference details of author lists.
*Table III of Chau 2014 provides an aggregate analysis of all acute injuries for male railroad workers by length of service, and shows that the new workers are at significantly elevated risk compared to the most experienced workers. According to our evidence synthesis procedures, this aggregate of all acute injuries analysis takes priority over the stratified injury analyses provided in Chau 2010.