Table 3

Quality scores of the included studies

Exposure, first author (year) Study design Follow-up time Response rate Exposure measure Exposure–response relation Confounder control Total score
Cotton workers
Glindmeyer (1991)30 1001103
Wang (2003)31 1011115
Wang (2005)14 1111116
Grain workers
Huy (1991)32 1111116
Olfert (2005)33 1000113
Pahwa (2008)15 1110115
Post (1998)34 1001114
Senthilselvan (2010)35 1110115
Farmers
Bolund (2015)36 1111116
Gainet (2007)37 1110115
Iversen (2000)20 1110014
Mauny (1997)38 1010103
Schwartz (1995)21 1011115
Senthilselvan (1997) 39 1010013
Thaon (2011)16 1110115
Vogelzang (1998)40 1011104
Paper workers
Sigsgaard (2004)19 1111105
Wood workers
Glindmeyer (2008)41 1001114
Jacobsen (2008)42 1111116
Noertjojo (1996)43 1111116
  • Study design (longitudinal=1), follow-up time (≥6 years=1, <6 years=0), response rate (>50%=1, <50% or unknown=0), exposure measure (dust measurements=1, no dust measurements=0), exposure–response relation (analysed=1, not analysed=0), and confounder control (all of smoking, sex, age and height=1, other=0).