Table 1

Prevalence of LRS course by demographic factors, insurance, exposure to the disaster and mental health conditions; bivariate analysis*, N=18 913

LRS course
Total†No LRSLRS at W1 onlyLRS at W1 and W2 onlyLRS at W1, W2 and W3
−,−,−+,−,−+,+,−+,+,+
Per centPer centPer centPer cent
Factor18 91347.127.211.114.7
Gender
 Male11 90345.727.011.415.9
 Female701049.427.510.612.5
Age category at 9/11/2001
 18–2488559.226.96.17.8
 25–4410 29145.728.411.314.5
 45–64726447.225.711.315.8
 ≥6547351.623.011.813.5
Eligibility group
 Rescue/Recovery workers899541.727.612.018.7
 Residents249452.427.29.710.7
 Area workers659152.226.610.410.7
 Passersby81648.927.010.513.6
Race/ethnicity
 White non-Hispanic14 07050.326.410.013.2
 Black non-Hispanic162637.631.015.316.2
 Hispanic182132.628.014.824.6
 Asian88449.229.610.211.0
 Other51236.128.315.220.3
Education‡
 High school or less361735.926.014.223.8
 Some college443337.628.413.620.4
 College/post-graduate10 78054.727.19.09.2
BMI reported at W3‡
 Normal (<25)568855.726.48.69.4
 Overweight (25–29)748647.327.910.814.0
 Obese (≥30)543337.827.014.121.1
Smoking at W3‡
 Every day104929.523.216.830.6
 Some days70936.229.214.120.5
 Not at all16 90848.727.310.613.4
Social integration at W3‡
 Low259734.527.813.124.6
 Medium719147.827.110.914.1
 High860750.227.210.612.0
Lacking health insurance‡
 No16 31548.427.210.913.5
 Some time since 9/11 but not in past 12 months136341.726.911.120.4
 Lacking in past 12 months91734.627.613.324.5
Exposure scale‡
 Low487463.821.66.77.9
 Medium797048.827.111.013.1
 High437335.431.513.719.3
 Very high169620.932.417.529.3
Probable PTSD at W2
 No15 53053.227.99.49.5
 Yes289316.823.419.840.0
Probable PTSD at W3
 No15 81752.028.010.010.0
 Yes244117.522.116.843.6
Probable depression at W3
 No15 88051.628.010.110.3
 Yes248120.021.816.641.5
Probable GAD at W3
 No16 46650.327.810.411.5
 Yes195121.921.416.440.3
  • *All factors are significant by χ2 at p<0.0001.

  • †The total may not add to 100% due to rounding and may be <18 913 due to missing data.‡Cochran-Armitage trend test for persistent LRS versus other three categories significant at p<0.0001.

  • BMI, body mass index; GAD, generalised anxiety disorder; LRS, lower respiratory symptoms; PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder; W1, Wave 1; W2, Wave 2; W3, Wave 3.