Table 3

Ratings on AGREE domains and mean scores per domain as a percentage of maximum possible score

AGREE domains1. Scope and purpose2. Stakeholder involvement3. Rigour of development4. Clarity and presentation5. Applicability6. Editorial independenceOverall score
Guidelines
 1. The Netherlands (2007): Mental health problems for OPs94835464444667
 2. The Netherlands (2011): MD adjustment disorder and burnout89756789486767
 3. The Netherlands (2011):
MD severe mental illness
100899275464296
 4. The Netherlands (2011): LESA adjustment disorder and burnout75695275543858
 5. The Netherlands (2006): Unexplained symptoms and somatisation64472250381342
 6. Netherlands (2003): Work-related stress47501139152921
 7. The Netherlands (2005): Work and psychological symptoms72531436194225
 8. UK (2008): NHS mental health81581050131725
 9. UK (2005): BOHRF common mental health problems94615953131358
 10. Japan (2009): RTW mental health problems5347367462975
 11. Finland (2009): Depression4733243619833
 12. Finland (2010): Work-related stress39392528251733
 13. Republic of Korea (2011): Stress after disaster at workplace86865394584233
 14. Republic of Korea (2011): Job stress81694681273358
Mean scores7361.53859.7333149.4
  • AGREE, Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation; BOHRF, British Occupational Health Research Foundation; GP, general practitioner; MD, multidisciplinary guideline; NHS, National Health Service; OP, occupational physician; RTW, return to work.