Major domains of bias | Minor domains of bias | ||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Exposure definition | Exposure assessment | Reliability of exposure assessment | Analysis /research specific bias | Confounding | Attrition | Blinding of assessors | Selective reporting | Funding | Conflict of interest | nrLR major | nrLR minor | HR/LR | |
Andersen et al1 | LR | LR | UR | LR | LR | LR | HR | LR | LR | UR | 4 | 3 | LR |
Harkness et al22 | LR | LR | UR | LR | LR | HR | HR | LR | LR | UR | 4 | 2 | LR |
Hoozemans et al23 | LR | LR | LR | LR | LR | HR | LR | LR | UR | UR | 5 | 2 | LR |
Hughes et al31 | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | UR | UR | 0 | 1 | HR |
Seidler et al11 33 34 | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR | HR | HR | LR | UR | LR | 2 | 2 | HR |
Smedley et al9 | LR | HR | UR | LR | UR | HR | HR | LR | LR | UR | 2 | 2 | HR |
Van der Beek et al32 | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | UR | UR | 0 | 1 | HR |
HR, high risk of bias; HR/LR, final score of study for high risk (HR) or low risk (LR) of bias;
LR, low risk of bias; nrLR major, number of domains with LR in the major 5 domains; nrLR minor, number of domains with LR in the minor 5 domains; UR, unclear risk.