Table 3

Coefficients (and SEs) from a series of longitudinal random-intercept regression models assessing the relationship between employment circumstances and mental health

Model AModel BModel CModel DModel E
Add covariatesAdd neuroticismAdd between-personLagged predictors of change in mental health
Employment continuum
 Optimal jobs5.95 (0.33)***5.77 (0.33)***5.40 (0.35)***5.04 (0.34)***6.27 (0.79)***
 1 Adversity4.10 (0.32)***4.00 (0.32)***3.84 (0.34)***3.38 (0.33)***4.26 (0.78)***
 2 Adversities2.42 (0.33)***2.32 (0.33)***2.40 (0.35)***1.85 (0.33)***2.89 (0.83)***
 Poorest jobs(Ref)(Ref)(Ref)(Ref)(Ref)
 Unemployment−0.07 (0.55)1.36 (0.55)*1.61 (0.58)**1.36 (0.56)*3.09 (1.32)*
 NILF0.49 (0.39)2.07 (0.39)***2.00 (0.41)***1.89 (0.40)***2.20 (0.81)**
Sex−0.75 (0.31)*−1.38 (0.30)***−0.45 (0.32)0.28 (0.27)
Age0.09 (0.02)***0.01 (0.02)0.09 (0.02)***0.06 (0.01)***
Physical health0.15 (0.01)***0.15 (0.01)***0.15 (0.01)***0.08 (0.01)***
Partner status2.62 (0.25)***2.67 (0.26)***2.53 (0.25)***0.59 (0.29)
Time in work4.84 (0.66)***4.23 (0.65)***3.70 (0.68)***2.53 (0.59)***
Education (higher degree)(Ref)(Ref)(Ref)(Ref)
 Diploma/certificate−0.47 (0.35)0.31 (0.34)−0.25 (0.35)−0.18 (0.32)
 High school−0.01 (0.42)0.69 (0.41)0.03 (0.42)0.18 (0.38)
 Incomplete high school−0.56 (0.38)0.41 (0.37)−0.43 (0.38)−0.05 (0.34)
Low SES area−0.15 (0.23)−0.07 (0.24)−0.03 (0.23)0.07 (0.28)
Experience of hardship−4.82 (0.29)***−4.52 (0.30)***−4.64 (0.29)***−2.11 (0.46)***
Neuroticism5.26 (0.03)***
Any experience of poorest quality job−3.47 (0.38)***
Any experience of unemployment−2.02 (0.52)***
Any experience of NILF−2.37 (0.37)***
Lagged mental health score−0.50 (0.009)***
Wave0.02 (0.03)0.05 (0.14)0.03 (0.03)−0.04 (0.06)
Constant70.43 (0.34)48.85 (1.08)25.49 (1.23)52.24 (1.11)21.34 (1.35)
  • * p<0.05; **p<0.01; *** p<0.001.

  • NILF, not participating in the labour force; SES, socio-economic status.