Table 4

Rated quality of reviewed studies

Rona et al 14 Mansfield et al 24 McCarroll et al 25 Hotopf et al 20 Adler et al 22 Ames et al 23 Grieger et al 21 Steel-Fisher et al 26 Chaudhury et al 27
Type of study222222222
Sampling method212222121
Aimed to assess tour length111111011
Prospective100000100
Appropriate control group111100111
Method of health outcome assessment232222212
Sample size233211000
Response rate greater than 60%111111100
Adjusted for confounders of tour length111111110
Appropriate statistical tests used111111111
Conclusions substantiated by results111111110
Quality Score15151514121211108
Overall quality in relation to tour lengthVery HighVery HighVery HighHighHighHighModerateModerateLow