Table 1 Hip osteoarthritis: assessment of study quality*
Authors†Design and materialAdjusted for confoundersMeasurement of outcomeMeasurement of exposureData presentation, statistical analysisQuality assessment‡ total score
Lindberg, 198437101103+
Typpö T, 198524201115+
Jacobsen, 198720100113+
Thelin, 1990342132210++
Vingaard, 199127211228++
Vingaard, 199122 253322313+++
Vingaard, 199226101226++
Croft, 1992162332313+++
Croft, 1992312221310+++
Axmacher, 199330210205+
Roach, 199423221229++
Jensen, 199432212128++
Vingaard, 1997283332314+++
Thelin, 1997333222211+++
Coggon, 199815§2232312+++
Cviteticl, 199917220127++
Yoshimura, 200029222129++
Lau, 200021112228++
Flugsrud, 2002182231311+++
Tüchsen, 2003363122311+++
Thelin, 2004352222210++
Jacobsen, 200438103307++
  • *Each item was scored from 1–3. Quality of the study was assessed by the sum of the scores, the maximum being 15 points.

  • †Several of the studies included more than one exposure, and have been cited more than once.

  • ‡The papers were subdivided into “+” poor quality (score 1–5); “++” medium quality (score 6–10); “+++” high quality (score 11–15).

  • §The study only scored 5 points (+) in relation to the study of farmers.