Study(IV score) | Methods | Subjects | Intervention | Outcomes | Results |
Exercise at work | |||||
Gundewall | RCT: stratified then | 69 nurses/nursing | (1) 20-min strength, endurance, | LBP intensity, number | Reduction of LBP |
et al30 | random allocation | aides with and | coordination exercise (6 sessions/ | of days with LBP, lost | prevalence (p<0.02), LBP |
(2.5/6) | to 2 groups. Follow- | without LBP work- | month for 13 months); (2) no | work days due to LBP | intensity (p<0.04) and lost |
up 13 months | ing in hospital | intervention | work days (p<0.01) | ||
Wigaeus | RCT: random | 131 nursing | All sessions 40 min, 2×/week for | LBP intensity | Unclear: Josephson et al26 |
Hjelm | allocation to 3 | aides working | 6 months: (1) bicycle ergometer; | report no significant | |
et al,25 | groups. Follow- | in hospital | (2) 3×15 repetitions on 7 | differences; Wigaeus Hjelm | |
Josephson | up 6 months | equipments; (3) education in | et al25 report reduced LBP in (1) | ||
et al26 | occupational health and stress | and (2) vs (3) in those with | |||
(1.5/6) | management | LBP at baseline | |||
Dehlin | NCT: allocation by | 46 female nursing | 2×/week for 8 weeks: | Frequency, intensity, | Reduction in LBP duration |
et al28 | work building to 3 | aides with | (1) strengthening exercise; (2) 30- | duration of LBP and | in (1) vs (2). No other |
(0/6) | groups. Follow-up | LBP working | min lectures on medicine and | influence of LBP on | significant differences |
8 weeks | in hospital | nursing care; (3) no intervention | working capacity | ||
Dehlin | NCT: allocation by | 45 female nursing | 2×/week for 8 weeks: (1) 45-min | Frequency, intensity, | No significant differences |
et al29 | work building to 3 | aides with LBP | endurance and aerobic exercise; | duration of LBP and | |
(0/6) | groups. Follow-up | working in | (2) manual handling training; | influence of LBP on | |
8 weeks | hospital | (3) no intervention | working capacity | ||
Exercise at home | |||||
Horneij | RCT: random | 282 female | (1) Posture, balance, endurance, | LBP prevalence, | No significant differences in |
et al27 | allocation to 3 | nursing aides | functional, stretching and | interference with | LBP, but (1) had less activity |
(4.5/6) | groups. Follow-up | working in home- | cardiovascular exercises | activities, pain | interference compared with (3) |
12 and 18 months | care services | (suggested ⩾2×/week); (2) stress | drawing | at 12-month follow-up | |
reduction training 7×1.5 h | |||||
plus follow-up; (3) “live as usual” |
IV, internal validity.