Table 3 Trials of exercise interventions
Study(IV score)MethodsSubjectsInterventionOutcomesResults
Exercise at work
GundewallRCT: stratified then69 nurses/nursing(1) 20-min strength, endurance,LBP intensity, numberReduction of LBP
et al30random allocationaides with andcoordination exercise (6 sessions/of days with LBP, lostprevalence (p<0.02), LBP
(2.5/6)to 2 groups. Follow-without LBP work-month for 13 months); (2) nowork days due to LBPintensity (p<0.04) and lost
up 13 monthsing in hospitalinterventionwork days (p<0.01)
WigaeusRCT: random131 nursingAll sessions 40 min, 2×/week forLBP intensityUnclear: Josephson et al26
Hjelmallocation to 3aides working6 months: (1) bicycle ergometer;report no significant
et al,25groups. Follow-in hospital(2) 3×15 repetitions on 7differences; Wigaeus Hjelm
Josephsonup 6 monthsequipments; (3) education inet al25 report reduced LBP in (1)
et al26occupational health and stressand (2) vs (3) in those with
(1.5/6)managementLBP at baseline
DehlinNCT: allocation by46 female nursing2×/week for 8 weeks:Frequency, intensity,Reduction in LBP duration
et al28work building to 3aides with(1) strengthening exercise; (2) 30-duration of LBP andin (1) vs (2). No other
(0/6)groups. Follow-upLBP workingmin lectures on medicine andinfluence of LBP onsignificant differences
8 weeksin hospitalnursing care; (3) no interventionworking capacity
DehlinNCT: allocation by45 female nursing2×/week for 8 weeks: (1) 45-minFrequency, intensity,No significant differences
et al29work building to 3aides with LBPendurance and aerobic exercise;duration of LBP and
(0/6)groups. Follow-upworking in(2) manual handling training;influence of LBP on
8 weekshospital(3) no interventionworking capacity
Exercise at home
HorneijRCT: random282 female(1) Posture, balance, endurance,LBP prevalence,No significant differences in
et al27allocation to 3nursing aidesfunctional, stretching andinterference withLBP, but (1) had less activity
(4.5/6)groups. Follow-upworking in home-cardiovascular exercisesactivities, paininterference compared with (3)
12 and 18 monthscare services(suggested ⩾2×/week); (2) stressdrawingat 12-month follow-up
reduction training 7×1.5 h
plus follow-up; (3) “live as usual”
  • IV, internal validity.