Table 1 Methodological quality criteria
Score
Internal validity (IV) criteria
AMethod of randomisation adequate (eg, random number table)?1
BTreatment allocation concealed?1
CGroups similar at baseline regarding age, gender, history of back pain, area of work, pregnancy, nurse grade and baseline measures?1
DCo-interventions avoided or similar?1
Ei) Drop-out/withdrawal individuals adequately described?0.5
ii) Drop-out rate acceptable (<20% for short-term and <30% for long-term follow-up)?0.5
FIntention to treat method of analysis (irrespective of compliance, change in group status)?1
IV score6
Descriptive quality (DQ) criteria
GEligibility criteria specified?1
HIndex and control interventions explicitly described?1
Ii) Short-term follow-up measurement (⩽3 months post initiation of intervention)?0.5
ii) Long-term follow-up measurement (>3 months post initiation of intervention)?0.5
JSample size for each group described at randomisation and all important outcome assessments?1
KPoint estimates and measures of variability presented for primary and secondary outcome measures?1
Li) Sampling method adequate?0.5
ii) Participation rate adequate (>80%)?0.5
DQ score6
Total score (IV+DQ scores)12