Table 3

 Comparison of PF from real and simulated workplace studies

DeviceReal WPFSimulated WPFRatio simulated:real
* Respirators as identified in Howie et al.3
†Howie et al.3
‡Johnston et al.7
§Parker et al.9
Full-mask powered
    R2*55†11000‡200
    R3*49†22500‡459
    R4*8.4†998‡119
Air fed blasting helmet2870§>40000§>14