Table 6

Attributable risks of mortality (1979–81) from different air quality variables

TSP, 1979–81 
 All locationsTSP, 1970–74 
 All locationsTSP, 1960–64 
 All locationsTSP, 1979–81 
 TSP, 1970–74TSP, 1979–81 
 TSP, 1960–64TSP, 1970–74 
 TSP, 1960–64
RiskSERiskSERiskSERiskSERiskSERiskSE
Ages 15–440.00090.02140.01590.01500.03230.02150.01240.0232 0.00660.03300.02910.0257
Ages 45–640.00970.01420.00920.01010.0574*0.01750.00150.0158 0.00150.02760.03420.0214
Ages 65–740.01140.01170.0240*0.00810.0289*0.01420.00180.0129−0.00840.02140.00700.0170
Ages 75–840.00720.01080.01140.00740.0290*0.01190.00540.0119−0.00620.0180 0.01890.0142
Ages ≥850.01380.01060.0200*0.00770.0368*0.01080.01780.0119 0.02920.01670.0347*0.0131
Log mean0.00360.00850.01550.00610.0242*0.01000.00300.00970.01040.0125
Inhalable particulate network data
PM2.5, 1979–84 
 All locationsPM15, 1979–84 
 All locationsFine SO42−, 1979–84
 All locations

Ages 15–440.08970.05680.03560.06150.0940*0.0397
Ages 45–640.1013*0.04590.04910.05000.1117*0.0253
Ages 65–740.0618*0.02970.02140.03240.0707*0.0184
Ages 75–840.0791*0.02350.05120.02600.0759*0.0131
Ages ≥850.0649*0.02280.0555*0.02470.0492*0.0129
Log mean 0.0515*0.02100.02030.02410.0580*0.0114
SO42−, 1979–81
 All locationsSO42−, 1970–74
 All locationsSO42−,1960–64
 All locations
 SO42−, 1979–81
 SO42−, 1970–74SO42−, 1970–74
 SO42−, 1960–64SO42−, 1979–81
 SO42−, 1960–64SO42−, 1979–81
 FineSO42−, 79–84
Ages 15–440.00870.01170.01940.01220.0332*0.01050.01200.01480.00630.01730.01910.01480.01170.0333
Ages 45–640.0320*0.00860.0234*0.00920.0216*0.00800.0330*0.01090.0442*0.01170.0322*0.01080.0552*0.0195
Ages 65–740.0441*0.00670.0248*0.00710.00950,00650.0377*0.00820.0359*0.00940.0235*0.00830.0609*0.0111
Ages 75–840.0379*0.00580.0226*0.00580.0162*0.00540.0309*0.00690.0332*0.00810.0301*0.00680.0491*0.0104
Ages ≥850.0175*0.00570.0184*0.00570.0196*0.00440.0155*0.00650.0194*0.00630.0224*0.00590.01710.0097
Log mean0.0189*0.00540.01030.00560.0121*0.00440.0130*0.00670.0147*0.00710.0142*0.00620.0258*0.0088
S02, 1979–81
 All locationsS02, 1970–74 
 All locationsS02, 1960–64 
 All locations
 S02, 1979–81 
 S02, 1970–74S02, 1979–81 
 S02, 1960–64S02, 1970–74 
 S02, 1960–64
Ages 15–440.02100.01330.02040.01330.1778*0.04120.01830.01770.1847*0.0465 0.0911*0.0332
Ages 45–640.0379*0.00940.00940.00990.00340.03730.0390*0.01230.03330.0389−0.00370.0270
Ages 65–740.0202*0.00860.00340.00810.00810.02230.01170.01070.01760.0233 0.01140.0160
Ages 75–840.0233*0.00730.00520.0068−0.00270.01500.01260.00930.02000.0161 0.00210.0099
Ages ≥850.0263*0.00730.0236*0.00730.03540.01980.0347*0.00950.0484*0.0213 0.0439*0.0120
Log mean0.0225*0.00640.0138*0.00610.03480.01920.0185*0.00810.0541*0.0198 0.0386*0.0119
N02, 1979–81
 All locations
 N02 1970–74 
 All locations
 N02, 1960–64
 All locations
p<0.05.
Ages 15–44 0.03940.0235 0.02800.0309−0.07370.1158
Ages 45–64 0.01860.0174 0.01620.0219−0.05670.0972
Ages 65–74−0.01980.0134−0.0346*0.0178−0.03290.0481
Ages 75–84−0.02050.0110−0.02560.0150 0.00380.0310
Ages ≥85 0.0235*0.0098 0.00370.0123 0.04750.0257
Log mean 0.01200.0100−0.01170.0120−0.1785*0.0428
Peak O3, 1979–81
 All locationsPeak O3, 1970–74
 All locationsPeak O3, 1979–81
 O3, 1970–74
Ages 15–44 0.02070.0255−0.02380.03670.09200.0548
Ages 45–64−0.00680.0176−0.03360.02500.01500.0362
Ages 65–74 0.0303*0.0148 0.0415*0.02060.04670.0280
Ages 75–84 0.0278*0.0127 0.0465*0.01870.0744*0.0259
Ages ≥85 0.01280.0123 0.01270.01570.02180.0220
Log mean 0.00720.0108 0.00730.01470.03120.0204
Peak CO, 1979–81
 All locationsPeak CO, 1970–74
 All locationsPeak CO, 1960–69
 All locationsPeak CO, 1979–81
 CO, 1970–74Peak CO, 1979–81
 CO, 1960–69Peak CO, 1979–81
 CO, 1960–69
*p<0.05.
Ages 15–44 0.00540.0174 0.02180.0200 0.05060.0478 0.02440.0209 0.07480.0679 0.11910.0709
Ages 45–64−0.00600.0141 0.0327*0.0161 0.0704*0.0337 0.00160.0181 0.08440.0496 0.1163*0.0491
Ages 65–74−0.0251*0.0105−0.01360.0119 0.01000.0211−0.01830.0128 0.01440.0259 0.01770.0310
Ages 75–84−0.0331*0.0086−0.0250*0.0105−0.01240.0143−0.0382*0.0108−0.01580.0168−0.01200.0212
Ages ≥85−0.01230.0079−0.0202*0.0085 0.01870.0135−0.0201*0.0089−0.00730.0170−0.00400.0202
Log mean−0.0183*0.0077−0.00480.0077 0.00840.0149−0.01650.0089 0.01090.0218 0.02110.0231