Article Text
Abstract
Introduction Trichloramine (NCl3) is an irritant gas commonly found in the air of indoor swimming pool, causing health problems to swimmers and workers who are often exposed to this contaminant. ASHRAE recommends a supply air delivery rate of 4 to 8 air changes per hour to remove trichloramine in aquatic centers. However, the fraction of recirculated air can have a significant impact on the exposure level.
Objective The main objective of this study is to investigate the impact of air recirculation by mechanical ventilation systems on NCl3 exposures for five user groups: i) swimmers in the basin, ii) people sitting or iii) standing on the deck, iv) lifeguards in surveillance chairs and v) spectators in mezzanine area.
Methods Exposure to NCl3 levels in a 9300 m3 swimming pool hall located in Montreal (Canada) is evaluated with a computational fluid dynamic software (Fire Dynamic Simulator). Simulations are performed for five recirculation ratios starting from the reference case at 77% down to 0% (100% fresh air). Emission rate of NCl3 is based on equations found in literature for a fully occupied pool. The numerical model was experimentally validated with tracer gas injection in situ.
Results The tracer gas simulation results show good agreement with the experimental results. Compared to the reference case (77% recirculation condition), a 100% fresh air ventilation strategy decreases the NCl3 levels of the five groups from: i) 19%, ii) 31%, iii) 62%, iv) 61% and v) 77%, respectively.
Conclusion Reducing the recirculation rate reduces the NCl3 concentrations. However, recirculation of air has less impact on the concentrations in the breathing zones located near the water surface compared to the other zones. The best air quality improvement with the 100% fresh air strategy is for spectators. Other ventilation strategies have to be investigated to improve air quality in the lower breathing zones as well.