The effects of feedback and goal setting on safety performance at two construction sites

doi:10.1016/S0925-7535(96)00070-7

Safety Science

Volume 24, Issue 1, October 1996, Pages 61-73

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0925-7535(96)00070-7 Get rights and content

Abstract

An internal safety inspection has to be carried out weekly on building construction sites in Finland. This procedure is widely believed to be ineffective, as illustrated by the high accident rates in the building industry. In this study, a new method for weekly inspections, based on participation and the principles of performance management, was tested at two construction sites. Eight safety rules were formulated together with the safety personnel of the company. Once a week the supervisor and the workers' safety delegate observed the safety level, using a standard observation method. After baseline observations, an information meeting was organized for all workers, and thereafter the safety index of each weekly observation round was marked on a large graph on the wall of the dining room. The safety index rose from the baseline of 60% to 89% during the feedback at Site 1. At Site 2 the index rose from 67% to 91%. The stage of the construction process had no significant effect on the results; the index level of 90% was achieved at all stages of the process. The most visible change was an improvement in order and tidiness. The subindexes concerning protection against falling, machine safety, scaffoldings and use of personal protective devices improved to nearly 100%, which should prevent severe injuries in particular. The new audit method with weekly graphic feedback could well be a method for the construction industry to reach a radically higher safety level.

References (15)

R.B. McAfee et al.
The use of incentives/feedback to enhance work place safety: A critique of the literature
J. Saf. Res.
(1989)
M. Mattila et al.
Promoting job safety in building: An experiment on the behaviour analysis approach
J. Occup. Accid.
(1988)
J. Saari
The effect of positive feedback on industrial housekeeping and accidents; a long-term study at a shipyard
Int. J. Ind. Ergon.
(1989)
B. Sulzer-Azaroff
The modification of occupational safety behavior
J. Occup. Accid.
(1987)
D. Fellner et al.
Increasing industrial safety practices and conditions through posted feedback
J. Saf. Res.
(1984)
A.R. Hale et al.
Individual Behaviour in the Control of Danger
E.S. Geller
Performance management and occupational safety: Start with a safety belt program

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (49)

Impact of owners’ safety management behavior on construction workers’ unsafe behavior
2023, Safety Science
Construction safety is a serious issue in the construction industry, while workers’ unsafe behavior is one of the major factors leading to construction accidents. It is believed that owners’ safety management behavior has an important impact on workers’ unsafe behavior. However, the specific impact mechanism is not yet clear from the perspective of owners, resulting in that the role of owners’ safety management in safety performance is relatively low. This research aims to reveal the impact path and ability of owners’ diverse management behavior on workers’ safety behavior by establishing a structural model, which contains the dimensions under the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) and Behavior-Based Safety (BBS). Firstly, based on the theories, the key safety management dimensions in developers or owners were determined and the hypothetical model of the safety impact mechanism is presented. Then, a questionnaire survey was conducted in a large real estate developer in China, 2,991 valid questionnaires were collected. Empirical analysis was further conducted by using Confirmatory Factory Analysis (CFA) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The results show that objectives and assessments (OA) and safety organization (SO) have an indirect effect on workers’ safety behavior (WSB) through management practices (i.e., hazard and emergency management (HEM), and subcontractor management (SM)), while WSB also influences accident management (AM). Particularly, the path with the most impact power is OA-SO-HEM-WSB. These research findings can guide developers or owners to participate in the performance improvement of construction safety management.
Social impacts on hazard perception of construction workers: A system dynamics model analysis
2021, Safety Science
The hazard perception of construction workers plays a predominant role in their behavioral decision-making process under risk environment. However, the evolution mechanisms of hazard perception are still unclear, not only because it is hard to observe and measure, but also because the hazard perception is influenced by multiple social factors and workers have different personalities as well. Interactions between individual and social environment is the root cause of hazard perception’s adjustment. Therefore, understanding how these social factors interact and drive hazard perception is important for managers to understand how unsafe behavior is fostered. The study analyzed the interaction and causality between the social factors and individual’s hazard perception and categorized multiple feedback loops. Hence a system dynamics model was established and a series of experiments were conducted to simulate how the hazard perception evolves under different group environment. The results indicated that (1) dangerous situation tend to result in high level of hazard perception, but the hazard perception would fluctuate inevitably which explains why fatal injury rate stays high for years. And there is a marginal decreasing effect on safety supervision investment, which means when the investment is over optimal value, even the cost of safety supervision increases, but the effect is not noticeable. (2) The unsafe behaviors which is unlikely to cause serious accident are most difficult to regular. Applying both strict safety supervision and regular safety education may achieve an acceptable result. The result also suggested that the plain and simple but regular education is more effective on contrast to in-depth and systematic but long interval learning of safety knowledge.
Voicing for safety in the workplace: A proactive goal-regulation perspective
2020, Safety Science
Citation Excerpt :
Empirical studies show that organisations that clearly communicate safety goals achieve significantly better safety performance and compliance with rules and procedures, reduction of risk-conditions, inappropriate behaviours and accidents and injuries over time (Boyce and Geller, 2001; Cooper et al., 1994; Fellner and Sulzer-Azaroff, 1985). Although goal-setting intervention strategies lead to better safety outcomes, most research has traditionally focused on prescribed goals identified by management to improve safety compliance oriented behaviours (Bumstead, and Boyce, 2005; Cooper, 2006; Laitinen, and Ruohomäki, 1996; Ludwig and Geller, 2000; Marsh et al., 1995; Sulzer-Azaroff et al., 1990). These goals tend to focus on compliance with procedures and standards, rather than on the anticipation of future safety risks.
Safety voice refers to proactive communication actions that aim to improve safety by identifying current limitations and possibilities to create a safer workplace. This entails individuals to identify hazards and dangerous ways of working in advance, and provide constructive suggestions to generate a positive change. Drawing on goal regulation literature, we aim to investigate safety voice as a part of a dual safety-specific proactivity process: a goal generation phase characterised by mental simulation and anticipation of risks (namely ‘safety envisioning’), and a goal striving stage which involves acting aimed at enhancing safety (here represented by ‘safety voice’). Study 1a provides support to the distinction between these two phases in a large sample of laboratory supervisors (N = 233). Study 1b showed the predictive validity of safety envisioning on safety voice (N = 71 managers). Study 2 evidenced the effects of organizational antecedents (perceived job control; supervisor and coworker support) on goal safety envisioning in a large sample of chemical workers from Central Europe (N = 157). Our paper adds an emergent stream of research by applying a goal-regulatory perspective in occupational safety.
Achieving sustainability in the construction supervision process
2019, Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity
In recent years, the construction industry faced major challenges in ensuring a balance between environmental, economic, and social aspects. There are a lot of different studies on different aspects of the construction industry. Most of the available studies look at the construction supervision process mainly from the constructor’s point of view. However, there is little research on the market surveillance and supervision process performed by the government and its role in ensuring sustainability in a particular area. The aim of this study was to identify the main activities within the construction supervision process to achieve the sustainability of construction. The theoretical framework of the concept of sustainability in construction and in the activities of the supervision process was analyzed on the basis of a literature survey. The research revealed a connection between sustainability elements and the construction supervision activities. The results of the survey identified the most important factors that influence, negatively as well as positively, the achievements of sustainability in the supervision process. The research results are significant in order to create a construction supervision process which would not only ensure the compliance with the set requirements but also help achieve sustainability in the particular area. Research Limitations/Implications: Research is focused on the supervision process of public building construction in Latvia.
A system dynamics view of a behavior-based safety program in the construction industry
2018, Safety Science
Citation Excerpt :
Results suggested that BBS was effective to reduce accident rate and severity. Laitinen and Ruohomäki (1996) found that feedback and goal setting had positive effects on safety performance at two construction sites in Finland. Similarly, Duff et al. (1994) implemented and tested feedback and goal setting methods at six construction sites in the UK.
Behavior-based safety (BBS) has received significant attention in the construction industry during the past decades. Ample evidence suggests that BBS is an effective accident prevention strategy. Past BBS literature is dominated by successful case studies, while unsuccessful cases and cases with mixed effectiveness in reducing unsafe behavior are limited. This paper reports a BBS program designed and implemented in the Singapore construction industry. The BBS program was aimed at reducing unsafe behavior in nine categories: lifting operations, excavation, working at height, work platform & access, manual handling, hot work (welding/gas cutting), plant & equipment, traffic management, and personal protective equipment (PPE). It consists of traditional BBS elements such as baseline observations, feedback, goal setting, and interventions. In contrast to other successful applications, the BBS program produced mixed results of safety behavior over 36 weeks. This paper adopts a system dynamics view to explain the mixed effectiveness. Causal loop diagrams were developed to capture behavior change mechanisms underpinned by reinforcement theory and goal setting theory, as well as dynamic effects of contextual and cognitive factors. It is concluded that the mixed effectiveness can be attributed to three main issues: dynamics of goal commitment, punishment, and monetary incentive. This paper adds to the body of knowledge of behavior safety program in terms of theoretical basis and implementation. By reviewing the BBS program holistically and reflecting upon the details of the case study, this paper offers lessons and reference for future design and implementation of BBS program in the construction industry.
Structural equation model of integrated safety intervention practices affecting the safety behaviour of workers in the construction industry
2017, Safety Science
Citation Excerpt :
Safety information and feedback are required in safety management at the workplace, and they have a positive impact on safety performance. As Laitinen and Ruohomäki (1996) shows, the safety index is significantly higher when feedback is given after goals are issued compared to when no feedback is given. Mohamed (2002) states that safety management audits assist a company in focusing on target responsibility on safety.
Fatality rates at workplaces in the construction industry are high compared to other industries. Tremendous effort is required to strive towards zero accidents. Managing foreign workers with different cultural backgrounds at the workplace requires appropriate safety intervention practices to improve workers’ safety behaviour. Based on the literature, the importance of safety intervention for changing unsafe to safe worker behaviour is known. For this reason, an integrated safety intervention model affecting workers’ safety behaviour was developed and tested. This study was conducted by distributing a questionnaire survey to construction companies. The survey was randomly distributed, with a total of 198 responses received. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was conducted to confirm the three safety intervention constructs. Structural equation modelling (SEM) was performed to identify the most significant intervention-related safety practices, which are to be the focus in handling safety management. The results indicate that technical intervention has a positive influence by management and human intervention. In addition, an improvement in workers’ safety behaviour can be achieved by focusing on the technical intervention with five important safety practices: workplace safety inspections, personal protective equipment (PPE) programmes, safety equipment availability and maintenance, safe work practices, and safety permits. These findings attempt to help construction management by identifying the appropriate selection of safety practices with specific interventions to improve workers’ safety behaviour.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

The effects of feedback and goal setting on safety performance at two construction sites

Abstract

J. Saf. Res.

J. Occup. Accid.

Int. J. Ind. Ergon.

J. Occup. Accid.

Increasing industrial safety practices and conditions through posted feedback

J. Saf. Res.

Individual Behaviour in the Control of Danger

Performance management and occupational safety: Start with a safety belt program