Original articlesAnalytic strategies for recurrent events in epidemiologic studies: background and application to hospitalization risk in the elderly
Introduction
Recurrent events, such as asthma attacks, migraines, low back pain, sickness leaves, or hospitalizations, are common outcomes in longitudinal clinical and epidemiologic studies. The main methodologic challenge in the context of recurrent events is how to deal with the dependence of events within a person. Different conceptual frameworks have been applied to deal with this problem in longitudinal studies. These include measures of proportion 1, 2, as well as counts 3, 4, 5, 6 and survival time 7, 8, 9, 10 approaches. These methods are rarely encountered in the medical or epidemiologic literature 2, 11, 12, 13, 14, however, and they are only briefly mentioned in a recent standard textbook of epidemiologic methodology [15]. The goal of this article is to bring recent methodologic developments in this important field to the attention of epidemiologists who may not be familiar with the pertinent biostatistical literature.
Section snippets
Review of methods
In the proportion approaches, the follow-up period is divided into fixed time intervals and cumulative incidences of events are calculated in all of these time intervals. Results of multiple time intervals are combined adjusting for the dependence of events within a person [e.g., by use of the Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE) method], as recommended by Zeger and Liang [1]. The width of these fixed time intervals should be chosen to make multiple events in a single time interval unlikely.
Background
In Germany, financial aid was newly provided in 1991 to severely handicapped individuals to cover outpatient nursing care. The aim of these benefits was to help handicapped individuals to maintain life in the community setting and to prevent admission to long-term care facilities. Benefits were provided by the system of health insurance contingent on an in-depth medical examination.
The cohort assessed in this article consisted of 2424 residents of the region of Augsburg (southern Germany) aged
Discussion
In this article, we provide an illustration of the application of several existing options for the analysis of recurrent events in epidemiological studies. We extend the recent illustration of the application of different analytic strategies modeling proportions [2] to the modeling of rates and include methods of count data and survival time approaches in our comparison.
All analytic approaches need some preparation of the data. The relative ease of adapting available programs for person-time
References (32)
- et al.
Methodologic issues in the study of frequent and recurrent health problems. Falls in the elderly
Ann Epidemiol
(1990) - et al.
Longitudinal data analysis for discrete and continuous outcomes
Biometrics
(1986) - et al.
Comparison of population-averaged and subject specific approaches for analyzing repeated binary outcomes
Am J Epidemiol
(1998) Mixed Poisson likelihood regression models for longitudinal interval count data
Biometrics
(1988)Comparison of methods for the analysis of longitudinal interval count data
Stat Med
(1993)- et al.
Estimating the variance of standardized rates of recurrent events, with application to hospitalizations among the elderly in New England
Am J Epidemiol
(1993) - et al.
Standardized rates of recurrent outcomes
Stat Med
(1994) - et al.
Regression analysis of multivariate incomplete failure time data by modeling marginal distributions
J Am Stat Assoc
(1989) - et al.
Cox's regression model for counting processesa large sample study
Ann Stat
(1992) Cox regression analysis of multivariate failure time datathe marginal approach
Stat Med
(1994)
Some approaches to the analysis of recurrent event data
Stat Methods Med Res
Hospital readmission rates for cohorts of medicare beneficiaries in Boston and New Haven
N Engl J Med
Ways of measuring rates of recurrent events
BMJ
Extension of the life table to repeating and changing events
Am J Epidemiol
Generalized Linear Models
Cited by (45)
Heart Failure
2016, International Encyclopedia of Public HealthPatient-level compared with study-level meta-analyses demonstrate consistency of D-dimer as predictor of venous thromboembolic recurrences
2013, Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyCitation Excerpt :The first empiric demonstrations of good fitting of Poisson regression compared with Cox regression in a single study on time-to-event data dates back many years [26,27]. Successive Poisson models, including fixed or random effects, were proposed as alternative meta-analytic approaches to pool rates and ratios calculated in follow-up studies and were often applied for studies with recurrent events [28,29]. When applied to recurrent event scenarios, Poisson and Cox analyses theoretically would answer two different clinical questions: the first looks at number of recurrences over a period, whereas the latter looks at time to (first) recurrence.
Inconsistent results in meta-analyses for the prevention of falls are found between study-level data and patient-level data
2011, Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyCitation Excerpt :One field where this is certainly the case is the prevention of accidental falls in hospitals. It has previously been argued that the rate of falls (number of falls by a patient divided by the length of time they are observed) is of greatest importance as an outcome in this field [9–12]. This is because considering only patients who fall or do not fall ignores the number of falls had by patients who had more than one (each of which having its own deleterious consequences).
Quantifying the magnitude of risk for balance impairment on falls in community-dwelling older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis
2010, Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyCitation Excerpt :And, although the OR is a valid measure of association in its own right, when an outcome is as common as falls in older adults, the OR overestimates the RR. Finally, logistic regression may not produce a risk estimate that is as informative as other regression-based methods that take into account the recurrent nature of falling [74,75]. Balance impairment is associated with increased fall risk in community-dwelling older adults with overall summary risk values of RR 1.42 (1.08, 1.85) and OR 1.98 (1.60, 2.46).
Comparison of Regression Models for the Analysis of Fall Risk Factors in Older Veterans
2009, Annals of EpidemiologyCitation Excerpt :This is despite the fact that nearly twenty years ago, Cumming et al. (11) highlighted the public health importance of studying the rate of falls, which involves analyzing all falls occurring in a study, rather than studying the outcome of “fallers.” Stürmer et al. (12) discussed a number of analytic strategies to deal with recurrent event data, and pointed out that these techniques can now be implemented using standard statistical packages. In the context of falling among older adults, Robertson et al. (13) compared the Andersen-Gill extension of the Cox proportional hazards (PH) model, the marginal model, and the negative binomial regression model, and concluded that the negative binomial approach had advantages over survival analysis.