Research reportSeverity of stressful life events in first and subsequent episodes of depression: the relevance of depressive subtype
Introduction
While the ‘endogenous’ or ‘melancholic’ depressive disorder has been traditionally linked to an absence of life event stressors, formal studies of the association have not been unanimously supportive (Leff et al., 1970, Thomson and Hendrie, 1972, Bebbington et al., 1981, Paykel et al., 1984, Roy et al., 1985). Two recent studies have reopened this scientific debate. First, Frank et al. (1994), studying patients with recurrent illness, found a close relationship between severe life events and non-endogenous—but not endogenous—depression. They demonstrated that endogenous depressed patients defined by the Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) experienced significantly fewer severe life stresses in the 6 months prior to episode onset. In a contemporaneous paper, Brown et al. (1994) found no difference in the rate of severe life events between RDC or clinically defined endogenous and non-endogenous patients. That group did, however, report that severe life events were less common in those with a score of ≥6 on a ‘melancholic/psychotic index’ than in those with a score <6 (i.e. non-melancholic patients). Furthermore, they found severe life events to be more common prior to the first episode of melancholia than to later episodes. In contrast, non-melancholic non-psychotic patients were no more likely to experience severe events in their first than subsequent episodes. These varying results reflect another issue of note—that any demonstration of specificity may hinge upon the definition of ‘melancholia’. The finding by Brown et al. (1994) of a closer association between life events and first (rather than subsequent) episodes of depression is consistent with a growing body of literature. Post (1992) has proposed that both sensitisation to stressors and episode sensitisation occur, and become encoded at the level of gene expression.
Other groups have reported a modest relationship between life stress and relapse or recurrence in severe recurrent depressive disorders. For example, Andrew et al. (1993) studied a sample of female inpatients with severe depression and found a lack of an association between psychosocial stress and outcome 9 months later. Similarly, Paykel et al. (1996) found that psychosocial factors such as life events and marital relationships appeared to played little role in predicting the outcome of inpatients with recurrent depression.
The aims of this study were: first, to examine the relationship between life events and contrasting depressive subtypes (melancholic and non-melancholic); second, to investigate the import of life events to first compared with subsequent episodes across those depressive subtypes; and third, to determine whether any evidence of specificity is dependent upon the system for melancholic sub-typing.
Section snippets
Method
A total of 270 consecutive depressed inpatients or outpatients fulfilling DSM-IV criteria for a Major Depressive Episode (present for less than 2 years) were recruited from subjects attending a tertiary referral Mood Disorders Unit (MDU) in Sydney, and a number of non-specialist psychiatric units in several Sydney teaching hospitals.
The methodology used in the study is described in detail by Parker et al. (1998). Patients completed a set of self-report questionnaires including a rating of the
Results
The mean age of the 270 patients was 43.3 (±14.9) years. The sample comprised 63.7% female and 36.3% male patients. The percentages of the total group of patients defined as ‘melancholic’ according to the four diagnostic systems were: DSM-III-R 44.1%; DSM-IV 38.9%; Newcastle 29.6%; and CORE 27.4%. A total of 16 (22%) patients in the CORE melancholic group did not meet criteria for DSM IV melancholia.
A total of 190 (70%) patients had experienced a previous episode of depression, whilst 80 (30%)
Conclusions
This study found high rates of acute and chronic life events of all levels of severity in the 12 months preceding the onset of a depressive episode, with at least 75% of all patients experiencing at least one such stressor. Additionally, on top of that high baseline rate, non-melancholic patients had a higher likelihood of experiencing both acute and enduring events compared with melancholic subjects. These findings were consistent across patient self-report (though this alone is of limited
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Zora Vuckovic and Anne-Maree Austen for manuscript preparation and Kerrie Eyers for helpful comments. This study was supported by the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council Program Grant 993208 and a New South Wales Health Department Infrastructure Grant Program.
References (21)
- et al.
Adversity and the nature of psychiatric disorder in the community
J. Affect. Disord.
(1981) - et al.
Psychosocial factors and episode number in depression
J. Affect. Disord.
(1987) - et al.
Life events in depression: relationship to subtypes
J. Affect. Disord.
(1985) - et al.
Do psychosocial factors influence outcome in severely depressed female psychiatric in-patients?
Br. J. Psychol.
(1993) - et al.
Life events and psychiatric disorders. I. Some methodological issues
Psychol. Med.
(1973) - et al.
Life events and endogenous depression: a puzzle re-examined
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
The diagnosis of depressive syndromes and the prediction of E.C.T. response
Br. J. Psychiatry
(1965) - et al.
Life events, depression and hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis function
Br. J. Psychiatry
(1985) - et al.
Life events and the research diagnostic criteria endogenous subtype: a confirmation of the distinction using the Bedford College methods
Arch. Gen. Psychiatry
(1994) - et al.
Life events and the recurrence of depression
Can. J. Psychiatry
(1990)
Cited by (62)
Investigating the association between fantasy proneness and emotional distress: the mediating role of cognitive coping strategies
2018, Personality and Individual DifferencesIdentifying Depression in Neonatal Intensive Care Unit Parents: Then What?
2016, Journal of PediatricsEverolimus improves memory and learning while worsening depressive- and anxiety-like behavior in an animal model of depression
2016, Journal of Psychiatric ResearchAn adaptationist perspective on the etiology of depression
2015, Journal of Affective DisordersCitation Excerpt :Several authors have suggested that these diagnostic criteria may be too broad or unspecific, may not “carve nature at its joints”, and may combine a variety of cases with distinct etiology (Andrews and Thomson, 2009; Frances, 2013; Hagen, 2011; Horwitz and Wakefield, 2007; Spitzer and Wakefield, 1999; Wakefield, 2013; Watson and Andrews, 2002). Accordingly, several authors have attempted to identify subtypes of depressive disorders based on clusters of symptoms that typically present together and may represent different etiological mechanisms (Ghaemi et al., 2013; Keller and Nesse, 2006, 2005; Keller et al., 2007; Kessler et al., 1997; McKercher et al., 2013; Mitchell et al., 2003; Ostergaard et al., 2011; Sharpley and Bitsika, 2013; Taylor and Fink, 2008). While this approach has had some success identifying patients that are more or less likely to respond to treatment generally, it has had little success predicting response to any particular medication or psychotherapy (Harald and Gordon, 2012; Simon and Perlis, 2010).
The implicit relational assessment procedure as a measure of implicit depression and the role of psychological flexibility
2012, Cognitive and Behavioral Practice