Assessment of workload and arm position during different work sequences: a study with portable devices on construction workers

doi:10.1016/S0003-6870(99)00016-2

Applied Ergonomics

Volume 30, Issue 6, 1 December 1999, Pages 495-503

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0003-6870(99)00016-2 Get rights and content

Abstract

It is recognised that work related shoulder pain is overrepresented among construction workers compared to other occupations. Studies have shown that working with hands above shoulder level increases the shoulder load. Most studies have been confined to the laboratory. The present project was carried out to map the muscular engagement and postures of construction workers undertaking ceiling fitting, and to compare the results to those of the laboratory studies. Two ambulatory devices were used, one allowing recording of electromyographic (EMG) signals bilaterally from the trapezius muscle, and the other to record the position of both arms and back by means of measuring the angles between the vertical line and the back and both upper arms. These recordings were performed during 1.5–2 h work sequences. The results show that the work was mostly performed in an upright position, that both arms were used to a similar amount and that the workers for a large proportion of their working time had their upper arms at levels that are considered harmful in view of shoulder load. The EMG data showed that nearly 50% of the work was spent with trapezius activity that exceeded that of the reference contraction used (about 15% of maximal voluntary contraction) and that the time spent in muscular relaxation was 10%. It was concluded that the exposure of construction workers undertaking ceiling fitting meets the criteria formulated on the basis of laboratory experiments with respect to a high risk of acquiring chronic shoulder pain, due to rotator cuff tendinitis.

References (0)

Cited by (36)

A people-centric sensing approach to detecting sidewalk defects
2016, Advanced Engineering Informatics
Citation Excerpt :
While such research has numerous strengths, distinguishing the subtle movements of a pedestrian using visual information is difficult. Recently, diverse research projects using sensory techniques have been performed to analyze such bodily responses as muscular engagement [38], fatigue [39], and gait stability [38,39]. Problematically, to obtain the information required for these projects, devices must be attached to the body, which in turn can affect human bodily response.
A defective sidewalk inhibits the walkability of a street and may also cause safety accidents (slips, trips, and falls) for pedestrians. When a pedestrian walks along a sidewalk, his/her behaviors may vary according to the condition of the sidewalk—e.g., whether the surface is normal, holed, cracked, tilted, or sloped. As a result, the pedestrian’s stability may also change according to the built environment’s conditions. Accordingly, this paper examines the feasibility of using pedestrians’ physical behaviors to detect defects in a sidewalk. Pedestrians’ physical responses and paths over a sidewalk are collected using an inertial measurement unit (IMU) sensor and a global positioning system (GPS). Then, after aggregating the pedestrians’ bodily responses and locations, the irregularity of multiple pedestrians’ responses are calculated in relation to their locations. The locations that show irregularities in the pedestrian-response patterns present a high correlation with the existence of a defect. The results of this study will help improve the continuous diagnosis of defects in sidewalks, thereby enhancing these built environment systems’ serviceability.
In search of a representative sample of residential building work
2012, Applied Ergonomics
Citation Excerpt :
Weather conditions can also impede or prevent use of electronic equipment in outdoor settings. For practical reasons, therefore, most researchers in the area of construction have used simulations or field studies with data collection periods of less than 5 h (Bhattacharya et al., 1999; Sporrong et al., 1999). Such studies have generally focused on only one or a few selected task types.
Most research investigating injuries in construction work is limited by reliance on work samples unrepresentative of the multiple, variable-cycle tasks involved, resulting in incomplete characterisation of ergonomic exposures. In this case study, a participatory approach was used including hierarchical task analysis and site observations of a typical team of house builders in New Zealand, over several working days, to obtain a representative work sample. The builders’ work consisted of 14 goal-defined jobs using varying subsets of 15 task types, each taking from less than 1 s to more than 1 h and performed in a variety of postures. Task type and duration varied within and between participants and days, although all participants spent at least 25% of the time moving from place to place, mostly carrying materials, and more than half the time either reaching up or bending down to work. This research has provided a description of residential building work based on a work sample more nearly representative than those previously published and has demonstrated a simple, low-cost but robust field observation method that can provide a valid basis for further study of hazard exposures.
EMG estimated mean, peak, and cumulative spinal compression of workers in five heavy industries
2010, International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics
Citation Excerpt :
However, given that the CNEMG methodology was developed using healthy participants, this discrepancy must be considered when interpreting results of the current study. Despite the limitations of EMG, it has been used successfully as a measure of working exposures in the upper limbs and shoulder (Earle-Richardson et al., 2008; Jones and Kumar, 2007a,b; Kothiyal and Kayis, 2001; Jin et al., 2009; Akesson et al., 1997; Østensvik et al., 2008; Sporrong et al., 1999; Straker and Mekhora, 2000; Capodaglio et al., 1996), the trunk (Earle-Richardson et al., 2008; Village et al., 2005; Keir and MacDonell, 2004; Lavender et al., 2007a,b, Lavender et al., 2007c), as well as the hip and lower limbs (Earle-Richardson et al., 2008; Jin et al., 2009). However, CNEMG is still a young method in terms of the number of published studies that have employed it; notably a lab-based study simulated lifting tasks (Mientjes et al., 1999), and an occupational field study of long-term care nurses (Village et al., 2005).
The goal of this study was to explore the use of compression-normalized electromyography (CNEMG) to estimate mean, peak, and cumulative loading of the low back in workers of five heavy industries and to compare the estimates to the NIOSH guidelines. Full-shift (5.5–10.3 h) EMG measurements were collected from 105 workers and transformed into units of low back compressive force (Newtons). The mean, peak, and cumulative CNEMG as well as the percentage of work time spent above 3400 N and 6800 N thresholds were calculated. Mean CNEMG (sd) was 1564 N (796), peak was 2721 (1545), and cumulative was 38 MN s (22). Mean time spent above the NIOSH threshold of 3400 N was on average 6.3% of shift, while mean time spent above the 6400 N threshold was around 1%. CNEMG allowed the feasible investigation of tasks and jobs that would be virtually impossible with more advanced biomechanical methods and represents a more objective measure of exposure than observation or self-report. CNEMG is a relatively new method with methodological limitations, however, CNEMG's strength may be as an objective, relative measure of exposure in studies where low back EMG is collected in a relatively systematic and structured manner.
Validation of tri-axial accelerometer for the calculation of elevation angles
2009, International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics
Citation Excerpt :
An inclinometer is a transducer that measures the elevation/inclination angle relative to gravity. Different types of transducers have been developed and are used to measure elevation angle exposure such as the abduflex (Fernstrom and Ericson, 1996; Svendsen et al., 2005) consisting of mercury microswitches, Intometer (Sporrong et al., 1999) consisting of pressure transducers and distilled water, Physiometer (Vasseljen and Westgaard, 1997) consisting of electrolytic liquid level sensors, and linear accelerometers (Bernmark and Wiktorin, 2002; Estill et al., 2000; Hansson et al., 2006, 2001a; Moller et al., 2004; Mathiassen et al., 2003). Linear accelerometers are commercially available and are commonly used in evaluation of segments' posture by means of uni-axial (Paquet et al., 2001), bi-axial (Boonstra et al., 2006) and tri-axial (Hansson et al., 2001b) accelerometers.
One of the main issues in occupational studies focusing on musculoskeletal disorders of the upper extremity is how to best quantify workers' exposures to risk factors during a workday. Direct measurement is preferred because it is objective and provides precise measurements. To measure elevation angle exposure of the upper extremity, accelerometers are commonly used. The main problem with the use of accelerometers is the fact that they are sensitive to linear acceleration and can only assess two axes of rotation. In the present study the Virtual Corset, a pager-sized, battery powered, tri-axial linear accelerometer with an integrated data logger, was validated in vitro for the reconstruction of elevation angles under static conditions and angle error prediction under dynamic conditions. For static conditions, the RMS angle error was less than 1°. Under dynamic conditions the elevation angle error was influenced by the radius and angular acceleration. However, the angle error was predicted well with an RMS difference of 3°. It was concluded that the Virtual Corset can be used to accurately predict arm elevation angles under static conditions. Under dynamic conditions, an understanding of the motion being studied and the placement of the Virtual Corset relative to the joint are necessary.
A device is tested that could capture posture exposure of the shoulder at the workplace during a workday. Such exposure measurement can be used to test interventions and to develop preventive guidelines to reduce risk factors associated with musculoskeletal injuries of the upper extremity.
Identification of ergonomics interventions used to reduce musculoskeletal loading for building installation tasks
2005, Applied Ergonomics
Citation Excerpt :
Between 1992 and 1998, 26% of all mechanical installation workers injuries and illnesses resulting in days away from work that were due to overexertion or repetitive motion (Fredericks et al., 2002). Studies have reported WMSDs among the electrical (English et al., 1989; Hunting et al., 1994), pipe (Hildebrandt, 1995; Ritz and Brunnholzl, 1988), and sheet metal (Welch et al., 1995) trades, and for similar work (Petersen et al., 1981; Herberts et al., 1984; Torner et al., 1991; Sporrong et al., 1999). Rosecrance et al. (2002) reported high rates of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) among apprentices working in the pipe, electrical, and sheet metal trades.
Skilled workers in the mechanical and electrical installation (M/EI) building and construction trades experience high rates of disabling work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs). The M/EI trades involve installing piping; heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC), and electrical systems in residential, commercial, and industrial buildings. In the absence of an ergonomics standard in the United States, some building and construction contractors, including M/EI sector contractors, have implemented various ergonomics interventions on their worksites on a voluntary basis. However, no data were available to determine the type of voluntary control measures being implemented, the task-specific hazards for which control measures needed to be developed or refined, and perceived barriers to improving hazard control. As part of a larger effort to obtain this data, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) organized a stakeholder meeting to gather information regarding ergonomics interventions or ‘best practices’ by M/EI contractors and tradespeople. The attendees included 39 industry representatives, 17 construction ergonomics researchers from government and academia, and four ergonomics consultants with experience in the construction industry. Participants spent more than 50% of time meeting in small trade-specific breakout sessions. According to the participants, tasks common to the three trades included (1) drill holes and shoot fasteners; (2) place and install systems, and (3) lift and carry materials and equipment. Engineering interventions described in the stakeholder meeting included tools, equipment, and engineered building materials; administrative controls largely consisted of training and education programs and modifications of work and management practice. Most participants believed that there were significant limits to the impact individual contractors and tradespeople could have in leading ergonomics improvement in the building and construction industry.
Continuous monitoring of upper-limb activity in a free-living environment
2005, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
Vega-González A, Granat MH. Continuous monitoring of upper-limb activity in a free-living environment.
To develop and evaluate a system for the objective measurement of upper-limb activity during a person’s activities of daily living.
Construct validation study.
Home and work environment.
Ten able-bodied participants and 10 stroke patients.
A novel activity monitor was developed for monitoring upper-limb activity. The Strathclyde Upper-Limb Activity Monitor (SULAM) gave a signal proportional to the vertical displacement of the wrist with respect to the shoulder. Participants wore the SULAM on both upper limbs for 8 hours while performing their normal daily activities.
SULAM-derived variables quantified the total upper-limb activity and the range in which movement of the upper limb occurred.
Data showed that the dominant arm of the able-bodied participants was 19% more active than the nondominant arm, whereas the unaffected arms of the group of stroke patients was used 3 to 6 times more than their affected arm. For all the variables, in both groups, there were significant differences between their upper limbs except for movement below midtrunk. There were also significant differences between groups for bimanual movement time (P=.000) and composite movement time (P=.000).
The results suggest that the quantification of vertical position of the wrist with respect to the shoulder might reflect upper-limb activity. By using the SULAM, it is possible to monitor upper-limb activity over the course of a person’s normal day, with minimal interference. This study provides preliminary evidence of the SULAM as a useful tool for objectively evaluating interventions aimed at improving upper-limb activity and function.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text