Table 1

Characteristics of study participants according to symptom pattern

CharacteristicAsymptomaticResolved LRSPersistent LRS
n=321n=110n=55
%*%*%*
Female sex52.362.778.2
Age on 9/11 (years)
 <2510.02.71.8
 25–4454.858.250.9
 45–6434.036.445.5
 65+1.32.71.8
Race/ethnicity
 non-Hispanic white76.058.238.2
 Non-Hispanic black6.219.116.4
 Hispanic4.410.027.3
 Asian11.510.07.3
 Multiracial and other races1.92.710.9
Education: college or higher85.774.650.9
BMI at exam 1
 normal/low (<25)57.333.621.8
 Overweight (25–29.9)28.031.840.0
 Obese (≥30)13.734.638.2
Dust cloud exposure on 9/11
 No64.232.723.6
 Yes31.564.665.5
PTSD (assessed 2006–2007)2.529.143.6
  • p Value for χ2 comparing patterns across three main symptom groups <0.001 for all characteristics shown except age (p=0.07).

  • *Percentages may not sum up to 100 due to missing data.

  • †Defined as a PTSD checklist score ≥44 on the 2006–2007 Registry questionnaire.

  • BMI, body mass index; LRS, lower respiratory symptoms; PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder.