Table 3

Sensitivity analysis comparing the adjusted (education, smoking status) hazard rate ratio* for the subcohorts recruited between 1985–1987 and those recruited in 1990, restricted to a similar follow-up duration of 18 years

Recruitment 1985–1987
All-cause (n†=207)Cardiopulmonary (n†=80)Lung cancer (n†=20)Respiratory (n†=9)
RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)
Distance from home to a major road
 >50 m1.00(0.53 to 1.56)1.001.00(0.62 to 15.62)
 ≤50 m0.911.20(0.54 to 2.68)–‡–‡3.12
1-year average
 NO21.22(1.04 to 1.43)1.58(1.19 to 2.09)1.25(0.72 to 2.17)1.15(0.50 to 2.68)
 PM10§1.48(1.08 to 2.04)2.49(1.39 to 4.44)1.97(0.59 to 6.57)1.34(0.24 to 7.56)
Recruitment 1990
All-cause (n†=322)Cardiopulmonary (n†=113)Lung cancer (n†=16)Respiratory (n†=21)
RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)RR(95% CI)
Distance from home to a major road
 >50 m1.00(1.21 to 2.31)1.00(1.11 to 2.93)1.00(0.73 to 11.61)1.00(0.26 to 5.64)
 ≤50 m1.671.812.911.21
1-year average
 NO21.22(0.98 to 1.61)1.50(0.95 to 2.37)0.39(0.15 to 1.04)1.37(0.45 to 4.24)
 PM10§0.99(0.77 to 1.27)0.85(0.56 to 1.30)0.64(0.22 to 1.84)0.95(0.36 to 2.54)
  • *Calculated for an IQR increase: IQRs were calculated from 1-year averages and rounded to 7 μg/m3 for PM10 and 16 μg/m3 for NO2.

  • †Number of fatalities.

  • ‡Not estimable.

  • §Calculated as PM10=0.71×TSP.

  • RR, relative risk.