Table 2

Characteristics of included studies

StudyLocation and year of the studyResponse rate (%)Study sample (n)Provision of the vaccineType of secondary carePredictors per study
DemographicBehaviouralOrganisational
Al-Tawfiq et al15Multi-national,* 200754.2450UnknownHospitalxxx
Beguin et al16Belgium, 199637.24109Free of charge to HCWs who wished to be vaccinatedUMCxx
Bull et al 24Australia, 200569.763 330Coordinated by the infection control department during autumnHospitalx
Christian17USA, 199063.3379Offered to all employees annually, $2 administration feeHospitalxx
Christini et al18USA, 200542.22467Free of charge, through advertised clinics and mobile carts, fact sheet providedUMCx
Lester et al19Canada, 200058.01195UnknownUMCx
Maltezou et al20Greece, 20068.98062UnknownPublic hospitalxx
Nichol et al21USA, 199438.01031Annual influenza vaccination program, walk-in clinic, mobile cartsUMCxx
Piccirillo et al22USA, 200487.0230UnknownCommunity hospitalxxx
Saluja et al23Canada, 200080.5426UnknownUMC emergency departmentsxx
Steiner et al10USA, 199984.22200Free influenza vaccination offered during mandatory tuberculosis screening of all employeesTertiary care hospitalxx
Tapiainen et al25Switzerland, 200475.5538Free of charge for all HCWsUniversity children's hospitalx
Weingarten et al9USA, 198741.1463Available to hospital employees at a $5 chargeAcute care UMCx
Total84 8801382
Average (95% CI)56.9 (43.1 to 70.7)
  • * Multi-nationality survey among HCWs from the UK, USA, South Africa and Saudi Arabia.

  • UMC (university medical centre) indicates a university medical hospital or teaching hospital.

  • HCW, healthcare worker.