Table 4

Effect sizes according to the exposure category of the exposed group in measures having significant heterogeneous effect sizes

TestExposure settingCohorts included (listed in table 2)NEffect size95% CIHomogeneity by group (p value)Homogeneity between groups (p value)§
Benton Visual Retention TestFarmworkers3, 4, 9253−0.72**−0.99 to −0.450.030.9
Applicators1, 2, 5, 19361−0.70**−0.92 to −0.480.01
Digit Span, forwardFarmworkers3, 4, 8, 9, 12, 16–18, 201087−0.45**−0.58 to −0.310.010.6
Applicators1, 2, 5, 10, 19460−0.39**−0.58 to −0.200.01
Finger Tapping, non-preferred handFarmworkers8, 12, 13, 16–18, 20866−0.17*−0.33 to −0.020.010.7
Applicators6, 7, 14188−0.11−0.40 to 0.190.34
Reaction Time, latencyFarmworkers3, 4, 8, 16–18, 20, 21935−0.32**−0.45 to −0.190.030.5
Applicators5, 10, 15340−0.23*−0.45 to −0.010.04
Digit SymbolFarmworkers3, 4, 9, 11660−0.53**−0.69 to −0.380.160.002
Applicators5, 10, 19360−0.14−0.34 to 0.060.52
Pursuit Aiming, correct dotsFarmworkers3, 4, 11603−0.62**−0.79 to −0.460.020.07
Applicators5195−0.31*
Trail Making A, latencyFarmworkers4, 9202−0.75**−1.05 to −0.450.230.03
Applicators1, 2, 5, 10, 19460−0.36**−0.55 to −0.170.001
Trail Making B, latencyFarmworkers4, 9, 13234−0.67**−0.95 to −0.400.870.2
Applicators1, 2, 5, 10, 19460−0.46**−0.66 to −0.270.002
Block Design, scaled scoreFarmworkers4, 9202−0.54**−0.84 to −0.250.240.4
Applicators1, 2, 5, 19361−0.70**−0.92 to −0.480.005
  • *p<0.05; **p<0.001.

  • Heterogeneous effect sizes are effect sizes with p<0.05 (last column, table 3), which means that there is a great variation in the individual effects sizes share in calculating the mean effect sizes of table 3. Here in table 4 the significant heterogeneous effect sizes are discussed.

  • Homogeneity by group is testing the homogeneity of the mean effect size for the two groups farmworkers and applicators.

  • § Homogeneity between group is testing if there is a significant difference between the effect sizes of applicators and farmworkers or not.