|
|
||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||
REVIEW |
1 Reader in Clinical Health Psychology, Centre for Outcomes Research and Effectiveness, Department of Psychology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK
2 Consultant in Occupational Medicine, Royal Free Hampstead NHS Trust, London NW3 2QG, UK
Correspondence to:
Dr S Michie, Reader in Clinical Health Psychology, Centre for Outcomes Research and Effectiveness, Department of Psychology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK;
s.michie{at}ucl.ac.uk
Accepted 14 May 2002
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Keywords: sickness absence; work stress; psychological ill health
L evels of ill health, both physical and psycho logical, and associated sickness absence are high among those working in health care in the UK.1,2 This problem is not unique to the UK.3 Poor psychological health and sickness absence are likely to lead to problems for patients in that both the quantity and quality of patient care may be diminished. Because most health care is provided by staff working in teams, ill health and sickness absence in any one individual is likely to cause increased work and stress for other staff.
Several explanations have been put forward for this high level of ill health, including the nature of the work, organisational changes, and the large amounts and pressure of work.4 A comparison across UK hospitals in the public sector found that rates of psychological ill health varied from 17% to 33%, with lower rates in hospitals characterised by smaller size, greater cooperation, better communication, more performance monitoring, a stronger emphasis on training, and allowing staff more control and flexibility in their work.5 This supports the notion that organisational factors may contribute to the level of psychological ill health experienced by staff.
To tackle the problem of work related psychological ill health, evidence is needed about the work factors associated with psychological ill health and sickness absence, and about interventions that have been implemented successfully to prevent or reduce psychological ill health and sickness absence. The primary focus of this review is the association between work factors and psychological ill health among health care staff. However, because of the paucity of evidence in health care,1 evidence was reviewed across all work settings, although presented separately for health care workers where appropriate.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Identification of papers
Four electronic databases were used: Medline (198799), PsychInfo (198799), Embase (199199), and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register (198799). Relevant papers up to and including 1997 were selected from a larger study.1 The search strategy in the larger study was of MeSH key words and text words in each of three categories: work factors; staff; and ill health/absenteeism/economic consequences. The search included all types of employment and all developed countries but was limited to abstracts in English. Secondary references were chosen from the primary paper references and by contacting academics researching this area. Psychological ill health included measures of anxiety, depression, emotional exhaustion, and psychological distress ("stress" was excluded since it is a mediating hypothetical construct rather than an outcome measure of psychological ill health). For the purpose of this review, papers from 1998 and 1999 were identified using the same search strategy, but excluding physical ill health and economic consequences.
Selection criteria
Abstracts were selected for retrieval of the paper if they were judged to include data about both work factors and psychological ill health or absenteeism. Dissertations were excluded, as were studies of very specific staff groups or settings, work patterns (for example, shift working), or events (for example, violence). All abstracts were selected independently by two researchers (three researchers were involved in this activity). The percentage of abstracts for which two researchers agreed about inclusion and exclusion varied between 80% and 90%. Disagreements were resolved by discussion.
Information extraction
Information from papers was extracted and coded within the following categories: study aim, study design, type of study population (for example, occupational group), sampling strategy, sample size and response rate, demographic characteristics, type of intervention, type of study measure, main outcomes, and summary of results.
Further selection criteria
Coded papers excluded from the review were studies with: volunteer or inadequately described sample; response rate of less than 60%; no standardised measures of psychological outcome.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
Associations with work
The results are presented in three groups: health care workers in the UK, health care workers in other developed countries, and non-health care workers. This enabled an assessment of whether associations between work factors and psychological ill health are similar across sector and country.
Health care
In the UK, factors associated with psychological ill health in doctors, from junior to senior grades, are long hours worked,9 high workload and pressure of work,7,16,11 and lack of role clarity12 (table 1
). Pressure of work has also been found to be associated with poor mental health in dentists.10 In family doctors, the issues were interruptions during and outside surgery hours and patient demands.16
Among UK nurses, the most frequently reported source of psychological ill health was workload pressures.17 Distress in student nurses has been caused by low involvement in decision making and use of skills, and low social support at work.13 In a study of health care workers across job type, bullying was found to be prevalent, carried out mainly by managers and associated with both anxiety and depression.14 Of the two studies addressing sickness absence, one found a negative association with job demands,13 while the other found no association with control over work.15
Similar factors are associated with psychological ill health in health care workers in the rest of Europe, the USA, and Australia (table 2
). The one study of doctors found an association between work control and social support and psychological distress.22 Among nurses, lack of co-worker support,24,27 job influence,26 and organisational climate and role ambiguity28 were associated with psychological distress. Among other hospital workers, work overload and pressure, role ambiguity, lack of control over work, and lack of participation in decision making were all found to be associated with distress.18,20,25
Sickness absence was associated with work pressures and lack of training,23 unsupportive management style,21 role ambiguity, tolerance of absenteeism, and low pay.19
Beyond health care
The picture among non-health care workers in Europe and the USA was similar to that of health care workers (table 3
). The key work factors associated with psychological ill health were: work overload and pressure31,34,36,3940,41,47,48; conflicting demands47; lack of control over work and lack of participation in decision making34,36,37,39,40,4648; poor social support at work31,33,35,38,39,41,47,48; unclear management and work role29,30,41,34,38; interpersonal conflict42,46; and conflict between work and family demands.46 Long hours were found to be associated with depression in women, but not in men.44
Sickness absence was negatively associated with high job demand,45 and positively associated with monotonous work, not learning new skills and low control over work,36,37,45 and non-participation at work.43
Evaluated interventions
Six intervention studies met our methodological criteria (table 4
). Three were randomised controlled trials,49,50,52 three were conducted in the USA,50,51,54 one in the UK,53 and two in Scandinavia.49,52 Three were of health care workers.50,52,54 Five were training programmes offered as part of the working day and one was an organisational intervention.53
Skills to mobilise support at work and to participate in problem solving and decision making were taught to care staff of people with mental ill health or mental disability in a randomised controlled trial.50 Groups of 20 had six sessions of 45 hours training over two months, and were trained to train those in their workplace. Compared to those in the control group, the intervention group reported more supportive feedback, more ability to cope, and better work team functioning and climate. Among those most at risk of leaving, those undergoing the training reported reduced depression. The second randomised controlled trial compared receiving support, advice, and feedback from a psychologist with having the passive presence of the same psychologist at staff meetings in a geriatric hospital facing organisational change.52 Staff were taught skills of stress management, and how to participate in, and control, their work. The intervention was an hour a fortnight during the 10 weeks before, and the 10 weeks after, the organisational change. There was a significant difference between groups, with a decrease of stress hormone levels in the intervention group.
Staff of a psychiatric hospital were taught verbal and non-verbal communication and empathy skills.54 Groups of 68 had eight hour weekly sessions for four weeks involving information, videos, modelling, and role playing. Compared to a matched control group, the intervention group showed reduced staff resignations and sick leave, although no statistical tests are reported.
Among physically inactive employees of an insurance company, a randomised controlled trial found stress management training and aerobic exercise interventions had mixed effects.49 After three sessions a week for 10 weeks, stress management training resulted in improved perceived coping ability but no change in physical or psychological health. Aerobic exercise resulted in improved feelings of wellbeing and decreased complaints of muscle pain.
Employees of a fire department underwent one of seven training programmes emphasising one or more aspect of stress management: physiological processes, coping with people, or interpersonal awareness processes.51 Weekly sessions for 810 people were run over 42 weeks. There was no control group. Compared to baseline, there were reductions in depression, anxiety, psychological strain, and emotional exhaustion immediately after the programme. There was a further reduction in psychological strain and emotional exhaustion at 916 months follow up.
A structural intervention for local authority staff on long term sickness absence was effective in reducing sickness absence. Referral to occupational health services was triggered after two or three months absence, rather than at six months which was the practice before the intervention. The average duration of sickness absence reduced from 40 to 25 weeks before resumption of work and from 72 to 53 weeks for those staff who left employment for medical reasons. The authors describe large financial savings but no statistical tests are reported.53
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The most common work factors associated with psychological ill health were work demand (long hours, workload, and pressure), lack of control over work, and poor support from managers. These were also associated with sickness absence. The findings of this review, summarised in tables 14![]()
![]()
![]()
, are consistent with the demand-control model of job strain.36 Interventions aimed at changing these workplace factors reduced psychological ill health.
Main messages
|
This review highlights limitations in the research identified. The studies that have been carried out are limited in the questions addressed and in the study designs used. Since most studies are cross sectional, causal relations cannot be shown. It may be that the associations found reflect a tendency for more vulnerable people to choose work in caring roles or other types of job which are well represented in published research studies. The question of what aspects of work lead to ill health and sickness absence can only be addressed by longitudinal studies that are able to investigate the causal relations between work factors and health outcomes and by randomised controlled trials of interventions. A longitudinal study that directly addressed the nature of the relation found a causal relation between psychological stress and psychosomatic complaints.55
There are several practical implications suggested by the studies of association in this review, for both employment practices and management style. Intervention studies, however, have focused mainly on staff training. There is a need for future studies to evaluate interventions based on employment practices and management style. This would represent primary prevention, reducing sources of psychological ill health, rather than secondary prevention, training individuals who are already experiencing work related stress, to be more robust in the face of such pressures. Only one of the intervention studies included an economic evaluation: such evaluations are important in facilitating employers to make decisions about whether or not to implement interventions.
Policy implications
|
Future research should adhere to minimum scientific standards absent in many of the studies reviewed, such as adequate design, sufficiently large samples, and valid outcome measures. Lessons that are learnt from rigorously evaluated interventions can then be applied more generally.
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| 1. | Williams S, Michie S, Pattani S. Improving the health of the NHS workforce. London: The Nuffield Trust, 1998. |
| 2. | Confederation of British Industry. Managing absence: in sickness and in health. London: CBI, 1997. |
| 3. | Whitley TW, Allison Jr EJ, Gallery ME, et al. Work related stress and depression among practicing emergency physicians: an international study. Ann Emerg Med 1994;23:106871.[Medline] |
| 4. | Cox T, Griffiths A. The nature and measurement of work stress: theory and practice. In: Wilson, JR, Corlett E, Nigel E, et al, eds. Evaluation of human work: a practical ergonomics methodology, 2nd edn. London: Taylor & Francis, 1995:783803. |
| 5. | Wall TD, Bolden RI, Borrill CS, et al. Minor psychiatric disorder in NHS trust staff: occupational and gender differences. Br J Psychiatry 1997;171:51923. |
| 6. | University of York. Understanding systematic reviews of research on effectiveness. CDR report 4. York: NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, 1996. |
| 7. | Agius RM, Blenkin H, Deary IJ, et al. Survey of perceived stress and work demands of consultant doctors. Occup Environ Med 1996;53:21724.[Abstract] |
| 8. | Baglioni Jr AJ, Cooper CL, Hingley P. Job stress, mental health and job satisfaction among UK senior nurses. Stress Medicine 1990;6:920. |
| 9. | Baldwin PJ, Dodd M, Wrate RM. Young doctors' healthI. How do working conditions affect attitudes, health and performance. Soc Sci Med 1997;45:3540. |
| 10. | Cooper CL, Watts J, Baglioni Jr AJ, et al. Occupational stress amongst general practice dentists. J Occup Psychol 1988;61:16374. |
| 11. | Deary IJ, Blenkin H, Agius RM, et al. Models of job-related stress and personal achievement among consultant doctors. Br J Psychol 1996;87:329. |
| 12. | Heyworth J, Whitley, TS, Allison Jr EJ, et al. Correlates of work-related stress amongst consultants and senior registrars in accident and emergency medicine. Arch Emerg Med 1993;10:27988.[Medline] |
| 13. | Parkes KR. Occupational stress among student nurses: a natural experiment. J Appl Psychol 1982;67:78496.[CrossRef][Medline] |
| 14. | Quine L. Workplace bullying in NHS community trust: staff questionnaire study. BMJ 1999;318:22832. |
| 15. | Rees D, Cooper CL. Occupational stress in health service workers in the UK. Stress Medicine 1992;8:7990. |
| 16. | Sutherland VJ, Cooper CL. Identifying distress among general practitioners: predictors of psychological ill health and job dissatisfaction. Soc Sci Med 1993;37:57581. |
| 17. | Tyler P, Cushway D. Stress, coping and mental well-being in hospital nurses. Stress Medicine 1992;8:918. |
| 18. | Arsenault A, Dolan SL, Van Ameringen MR. Stress and mental strain in hospital work: exploring the relationship beyond personality. Journal of Organisational Behaviour 1991;12:48393. |
| 19. | Brooke PP, Price JL. The determinants of employees absenteeism: an empirical test of a causal model. J Occup Psychol 1989;62:119. |
| 20. | Estryn-Behar M, Kaminski J, Peigne E, et al. Stress at work and mental health status among female hospital workers. Br J Ind Med 1990;47:208.[Medline] |
| 21. | Gray-Toft PA, Anderson JG. Organisational stress in the hospital: development of a model for diagnosis and prediction. Health Serv Res 1985;19:75374.[Medline] |
| 22. | Johnson JV, Stewart W, Hall EM, et al. The psychosocial work environment of physicians. J Occup Environ Med 1995;37:11519.[CrossRef][Medline] |
| 23. | Landeweerd JA, Boumans NPG. The effect of work dimensions and need for autonomy on nurses' work satisfaction and health. J Occup Organ Psychol 1994;67:20717. |
| 24. | Marshall NL, Barnett RC. Work-related support among women in caregiving occupations. J Community Psychol 1992;20:642. |
| 25. | Martin TN. Role stress and inability to leave as predictors of mental health. Human Relations 1984;37:96983.[Abstract] |
| 26. | Petterson IL, Arnetz BB, Arnetz JE. Predictors of job satisfaction and job influence: results from a national sample of Swedish nurses. Psychother Psychosom 1995;64:919.[Medline] |
| 27. | Pisarski A, Bohle P, Callan VJ. Effects of coping strategies, social support and work-nonwork conflict on shift worker's health. Scand J Work Environ Health 1998;241:41145. |
| 28. | Revicki DA, May HJ. Organisational characteristics, occupational stress, and mental health in nurses. Behav Med 1989;15:306.[Medline] |
| 29. | Bacharach SB, Bamberger P, Conley S. Work-home conflict among nurses and engineers: mediating the impact of role stress on burnout and satisfaction at work. Journal of Organisational Behaviour 1991;12:3953. |
| 30. | Carayon P, Yang C, Lim S. Examining the relationship between job design and worker strain over time in a sample of office workers. Ergonomics 1995;38:1199211. |
| 31. | Driscoll RJ, Worthington KA, Hurrell Jr JJ. Workplace assault: an emerging job stressor. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research 1995;47:20512.[CrossRef] |
| 32. | Ferrie JE, Shipley MJ, Marmot MG, et al. An uncertain future: the health effects of threats to employment security in white-collar men and women. Am J Public Health 1998;88:10306. |
| 33. | Frese M. Social support as a moderator of the relationship between work stressors and psychological dysfunctioning: a longitudinal study with objective measures. J Occup Health Psychol 1999;3:17992. |
| 34. | Frone MR, Russell M, Cooper ML. Job stressors, job involvement and employee health: a test of identity theory. J Occup Psychol 1995;68:111. |
| 35. | Fusilier MR, Ganster DC, Mayes BT. Effects of social support, role stress, and locus of control on health. Journal of Management 1987;13:51728.[Abstract] |
| 36. | Karasek Jr RA. Job demands, job decision latitude, and mental strain: implications for job redesign. Adm Sci Q 1979;24:285311.[CrossRef] |
| 37. | Karasek R. Lower health risk with increased job control among white collar workers. Journal of Organisational Behaviour 1990;11:17185. |
| 38. | LaRocco JM, House JS, French Jr JRP. Social support, occupational stress, and health. J Health Soc Behav 1980;21:20218.[CrossRef][Medline] |
| 39. | Niedhammer I, Goldberg M, Leclerc A, et al. Psychosocial factors at work and subsequent depressive symptoms in the Gazel cohort. Scand J Work Environ Health 1998;24:197205.[Medline] |
| 40. | Payne R, Fletcher BC. Job demands, supports, and constraints as predictors of psychological strain among schoolteachers. Journal of Vocational Behaviour 1983;22:13647.[CrossRef] |
| 41. | Reifman A, Biernat M, Lang EL. Stress, social support, and health in married professional women with small children. Psychology of Women Quarterly 1991;15:43145.[CrossRef] |
| 42. | Romanov K, Appelberg K, Honkasalo M, et al. Recent interpersonal conflict at work and psychiatric morbidity: a prospective study of 15,530 employees aged 2464. J Psychosom Res 1996;40:16976.[CrossRef][Medline] |
| 43. | Rubenowitz S, Norrgren F, Tannenbaum AS. Some social psychological effects of direct and indirect participation in ten Swedish companies. Organisation Studies 1983;4:24359. |
| 44. | Shields M. Long working hours and health. Health Reports 1999;11:3348.[Medline] |
| 45. | Smulders PGW, Nijhuis, FJN. The job demands-job control model and absence behaviour: results of a 3-year longitudinal study. Work and Stress 1999;13:11531. |
| 46. | Sparks K, Cooper CL. Occupational differences in the work-strain relationship: towards the use of situation-specific models. Journal of Occupational Organizational Psychology 1999;72:21929. |
| 47. | Stansfeld SA, North FM, White I, et al. Work characteristics and psychiatric disorder in civil servants in London. J Epidemiol Community Health 1995;49:4853.[Abstract] |
| 48. | Stansfeld SA, Bosma H, Hemingway H, et al. Psychosocial work characteristics and social support as predictors of SF-36 health functioning: the Whitehall II study. Psychosom Med 1998;60:24755. |
| 49. | Gronningsaeter H, Hytten K, Skauli G, et al. Improved health and coping by physical exercise or cognitive behavioural stress management training in a work environment. Psychology and Health 1992;7:14763.[CrossRef] |
| 50. | Heany CA, Price RH, Refferty J. Increasing coping resources at work: a field experiment to increase social support, improve work team functioning, and enhance employee mental health. Journal of Organisational Behaviour 1995;16:33552. |
| 51. | Kagan NI, Kagan H, Watson MG. Stress reduction in the workplace: the effectiveness of psychoeducational programs. Journal of Counselling Psychology 1995;42:718.[CrossRef] |
| 52. | Lokk J, Arnetz B. Psychophysiological concomitants of organisational change in health care personnel: effects of a controlled intervention study. Psychother Psychosom 1997;66:747.[Medline] |
| 53. | Malcolm RM, Harrison J, Forster H. Effects of changing the pattern of referrals in a local authority. Occup Med 1993;43:21115. |
| 54. | Smoot SL Gonzales JL. Cost-effective communication skills training for state hospital employees. Psychiatr Serv 1995;46:81922. |
| 55. | Frese M. Stress at work and psychosomatic complaints: a causal interpretation. J Appl Psychol 1985;70:31428.[CrossRef][Medline] |
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Jones, N. T. Fear, N. Greenberg, N. Jones, L. Hull, M. Hotopf, S. Wessely, and R. J. Rona Do medical services personnel who deployed to the Iraq war have worse mental health than other deployed personnel? Eur J Public Health, August 1, 2008; 18(4): 422 - 427. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
U.-B. Eriksson, B. Starrin, and S. Janson Long-Term Sickness Absence Due to Burnout: Absentees' Experiences Qual Health Res, May 1, 2008; 18(5): 620 - 632. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Vahtera and M. Kivimaki Reducing sickness absence in occupational settings Occup. Environ. Med., April 1, 2008; 65(4): 219 - 220. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. A. M. Roelen, K. J. Schreuder, P. C. Koopmans, and J. W. Groothoff Perceived job demands relate to self-reported health complaints Occup. Med., January 1, 2008; 58(1): 58 - 63. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Egan, C. Bambra, S. Thomas, M. Petticrew, M. Whitehead, and H. Thomson The psychosocial and health effects of workplace reorganisation. 1. A systematic review of organisational-level interventions that aim to increase employee control J. Epidemiol. Community Health, November 1, 2007; 61(11): 945 - 954. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Taimela, E. Laara, A. Malmivaara, J. Tiekso, H. Sintonen, S. Justen, and T. Aro Self-reported health problems and sickness absence in different age groups predominantly engaged in physical work Occup. Environ. Med., November 1, 2007; 64(11): 739 - 746. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Egan, M. Petticrew, D. Ogilvie, V. Hamilton, and F. Drever "Profits before people"? A systematic review of the health and safety impacts of privatising public utilities and industries in developed countries J. Epidemiol. Community Health, October 1, 2007; 61(10): 862 - 870. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Noblet and A. D. LaMontagne The role of workplace health promotion in addressing job stress Health Promot. Int., December 1, 2006; 21(4): 346 - 353. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K Harkonmaki, O Rahkonen, P Martikainen, K Silventoinen, and E Lahelma Associations of SF-36 mental health functioning and work and family related factors with intentions to retire early among employees Occup. Environ. Med., August 1, 2006; 63(8): 558 - 563. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J Wieclaw, E Agerbo, P B Mortensen, and J P Bonde Risk of affective and stress related disorders among employees in human service professions. Occup. Environ. Med., May 1, 2006; 63(5): 314 - 319. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS | REGISTER |